BY ERIC GIACOMETTI
Take it easy, Chicken Little; the sky is not falling.
Despite what most fans think, Sunday’s 4-1 loss to DC United is not the end of the world. Now that the pitiful effort and subsequent result has had some time to sink in, it’s time to put the debacle into perspective.
For starters, most fans had their expectations set way to high for this match. On the one hand, New York was on a good run of form (3-0-1 in the last four), so this mislead overconfidence isn’t exactly coming out of left field. Of course, I’m playing the role of Captain Hindsight here, but take a look at our starting XI last night.
Without Conde, Tainio, Rafa, and Miller, it’s hard to imagine this Red Bulls team performing as dominantly as their recent form had dictated. Just as we saw with the Gold Cup last year, missing starters is an enormous mountain to climb. As solid as Connor Lade had looked, he is, after all, a rookie. He made some rookie mistakes and the team ultimately paid for it (see DCU goal #2). Same goes for Victor Palsson. He was once again given a chance to prove himself in the starting lineup, and once again failed to impress (see DCU goal #3).
Now, that’s not to say that these two won’t come into their own throughout the course of the season, but expecting them to fit seamlessly into the lineup was perhaps a bit too optimistic. I’d have given Lindpere the nod over Palsson, but Backe says he doesn’t see him as a central midfielder unless deployed in a three CM formation. I guess he forgot about 2010…
Now before I go any further, let me send out this disclaimer: I am by no means turning a blind eye to our defensive woes. The back four have been absolutely deplorable, especially without Conde. The type of form displayed by our backline is simply not going to get it done in this league. Yes, Holgersson has been atrocious. Yes, Solli has shown little to nothing this season. But that doesn’t mean we should blow up the team and fire the manager, as many fans were crying out for last night.
At the end of the day, New York still stands in 3rd place in the East with a 3-3-1 record. There’s no need for panic just yet. Let’s worry about getting this team healthy before we jump to make such rash (hypothetical) decisions. At full strength, there’s no reason this team can’t compete for a place at the top of the table. And as was so kindly pointed out to me, Holgersson can’t really be that bad… can he?






I guess its true but still its a terribly put together team
im sorry but i have to disagree this team is so pose to be way way better then they really been those mistakes last night was a joke for a high paid team like red bull no way there going to win anything without great D this team as been a fail for years good players but in the end no cups to show for it. holgersson is really bad fifa 12 says it to 61 overall and hes not even a CB hes a right back a back up to not good to be a starter.
I’m sorry but Lade is not MLS material in my eyes. Yes, a short player can get by, but not on hops alone, as some reporters have raved about. He lacks strength and speed. New England will push him around if he plays. Both Luke and Dane get or got by in this league with their height, cause Dane has speed, and Luke was a Bull Dog!
I don’t think we can judge whether he’s MLS material or not yet, the kid’s played in just over one full match in the league. Pretty small sample size to write him off, if you ask me.
I also disagree with this article’s premise that we should just let the team get healthy. Time and time again, Backe has provided us evidence that he can not prepare a team to play in this league. Injuries are inevitable in any sport. However, the role of the coach is to prepare players to step in and fill holes when called upon. We can’t keep letting Backe slide every time his top-11 players are injured and as a result, we aren’t expected to compete. When up 3-0, use your subs in the 70th minute and get these inexperienced players some much needed playing time. It does them no good to sit on the bench each and every game. Nor does it do them any good to occasionally get as much as 3 minutes of game action coming on as 90th minute subs. Compare the way this team is managed to most other teams in MLS and it is clear that we have major issues…and those start at the top.
I’m not absolving Backe from blame whatsoever, I just don’t buy into the notion that this time is destined to fail. How many people were worried about our back four when Conde was healthy against Colorado and Montreal (goals against the Impact were Holgersson and Meara’s fault, respectively)? I agree that Backe should give his younger players more minutes, but he’s now in his third year as manager; don’t expect him to change his substitution philosophy now.
I agree Eric…Conde seems to make a lot of problems go away. However, knowing he was an injury risk, there was no reason to throw so much money at him. They basically overpaid for his services and now, we just have to hope that he can come back and make a difference again. In the mean time, we still continue to see the same mistakes being made on set pieces and we are left to wonder what exactly they practice during the middle of the week. My problem is not just with Backe not using his subs…he (and the other coaches) just don’t seem capable of getting a whole team ready to play.
I don’t want to be a bitter Red Bulls fan the rest of my life. I am somewhat over the bitterness of trading away a superstar that didn’t fit the coach’s style for a player that we could possibly get a 3rd-round pick for. I can even get over the bitterness of the coach deciding that our MVP the last 2 seasons is no longer worthy of a starting spot in his top XI. However, I will never get over the bitterness of a coach that trots these guys out on the pitch week after week and being forced asa fan to endure them messing up on the basics of the game I love.
As you said, he is in his third year. Tell me where he has improved the team in his 3 years here. Scoring might be up, but I think that is more of Henry’s skill and Rodgers’ passion last season. Cooper has been a great addition, but take away Henry from the equation and I can’t say Cooper would still be in the top-3 in scoring in the league. I would love to be calm as you suggest in your article, but how can I when this team doesn’t seem to get better week after week. I just wished the folks in Austria cared as much as some of our fans, because if they did, Soler and Backe would have been fired by now. Do you think Backe would have lasted this long on another high-profile club in any other country’s top division?
[...] I believe we move on, we accept that the team had a bad night. As another RBNY writer put this is no time for panic. This is a time for the fans to rally around the team, get loud, and make the New England [...]